Judgement 56 (Wes) Mon, 4 Oct 93 13:47:07 CDT Alexx has committed a Class C Crime, as per Rule 455, by not including a Declaration in Proposal 475 (Old Players). He shall therefore be penalized 8 Points as per Rule 425. Explanation: The Voting Periods for Rules 454 and 455 ended on Thursday, September 9. The Voting Period for the earliest of these Proposals, 468, ended on Monday, September 20. This is an 11 day difference. It should also be noted that Proposals 461 to 465 were submitted by us less than 24 hours before the results of Rules 454 and 455 were posted to the list, thus making them effective, and they were distributed on Friday, September 17. Therefore, we contend that all of these Proposals were submitted after Rules 454 and 455 took effect, making them all subject to those Rules. Even if the borderline cases are removed, each Proposal was submittd later than the last, with Proposal 475 being distributed a full week after this date. Therefore, even if the first few are found to be FALSE, for whatever reason, the later ones should surely be found TRUE. Judge: Oerjan (accepted Tue, 5 Oct 1993 15:40:53 +0100 (MET)) Judgement: TRUE