====================================================================== CFJ 1107 A Recordkeepor is not required to abide by a valid Transfer Order under the condition that this transfer "would result in an entity possessing a negative quantity of Currency" (R1817). However, as soon as this condition ceases to be true, the Transfer Order in question must be obeyed. ====================================================================== Judge: Blob Judgement: Eligible: Antimatter, Blob, Chuck, General Chaos, Harlequin, Macross, Michael, Morendil, Murphy, Proglet, Steve Not eligible: Caller: Kolja A. Barred: Crito, Lee Disqualified: - On hold: elJefe, Oerjan ====================================================================== History: Called by Kolja A., Tue, 15 Sep 1998 14:17:40 +0200 Assigned to Blob, Wed, 16 Sep 1998 10:16:10 +0100 ====================================================================== (Caller's) Arguments: While R1817 does not explicitly state when this condition is to be checked, it also says nothing about any change in a TO's status if this condition is true at some time or other. Therefore, as soon as the payor of the TO has sufficient funds to pay the TO, the situation is the same as in the standard case: there is a valid TO around, and there is no reason why the recordkeepor shouldn't be allowed and required to execute the TO. As an aside, I wonder whether there is anything that would stop a recordkeepor to make a transfer that leaves a player with a negative amount of currency? R1817 only says that in this case the recordkeepor is "not required to" make the transfer ======================================================================