====================================================================== CFJ 1072 "The Rulekeepor does not have an Official Report." ====================================================================== Judge: Chuck Judgement: TRUE Eligible: Andre, Calabresi, Chuck, Crito, elJefe, General Chaos, Kolja A., Morendil, Murphy, Oerjan, Steve, Swann, Vlad Not eligible: Caller: Michael Barred: On request: Vanyel On hold: Harlequin, Vir ====================================================================== History: Called by Michael, 13 Nov 1997 08:53:08 +0000 Assigned to Chuck, 13 Nov 1997 09:25:27 +0000 Judged TRUE, 18 Nov 1997 22:14:33 -0600 ====================================================================== Caller's Arguments: Though the rules pertaining to the Rulekeepor require them to post a copy of the ruleset every week, thy do not identify this as that Office's Report. ====================================================================== Reasons and Arguments of the Judge: I Judge this to be TRUE. R&A: Rule 1686 is clear on what constitutes an Official Report--it must include information designated by the Rules to be part of that Officer's Report. As Caller correctly notes, the Rules do not designate any information as a Rulekeepor's Report. Thus, the Rulekeepor has no Official Report. Evidence: Rule 1686 (All other Rules constitute negative evidence, but are not listed here in the interest of space.) Rule 1686/0 (Power=1) Official Reports For each Office, the Rules may designate a set of information to be the corresponding Officer's Report. All such Reports are Official Reports. The only information that is part of an Official Report is that which the Rules specifically state is part of that Official Report. The holder of an Office for which there is an Official Report shall maintain all information in the Report, and shall post it to the Public Forum at least once every Nomic Week. Failure to post the Official Report is the Infraction of Failure to Report, the penalty for which is the same as the penalty for a Class D Crime. The Registrar and the Speaker are authorised to detect and report commissions of this Infraction. History: Created by Proposal 2839 (Zefram), Mar. 11 1997 Originator: Zefram Author: Zefram ======================================================================